A Soul on Trial: A Marine Corps Mystery at the Turn of the Twentieth Century (2nd Edition), by historian Robin Cutler, is the true story of Rosa Brant Sutton, who traveled 3,000 miles from Portland, Oregon, to Annapolis, Maryland, to challenge the Navy’s suicide finding after her oldest son died in a brawl. Inspired by her Catholic faith and alleged postmortem visits from her beloved son, Jimmie, she embarked on a crusade to save his soul from the stigma of a mortal sin — a sin that would keep him out of heaven.
 |
| More photos related to this story can be found in the gallery at https://robinrcutler.com/a-soul-on-trial/a-soul-on-trial-gallery/ |
How did you come across this story?
After my mother died, I found a black enamel locket that had a picture of a midshipmen and a lock of chestnut hair inside it. At the time, I didn’t realize it was a traditional mourning locket. Or that the midshipman was Jimmie Sutton. A few years later, I came across a brittle 1910 newspaper clipping from the Los Angeles Examiner. The clipping referred to my great grandmother’s plan to run for Congress because of the sensational case related to her son’s death. I was quite surprised and began digging further into newspapers from the period. The more articles I read, the more astonishing the story became—and the fact that Rosa Sutton had been in the headlines all across the United States for months really got me hooked. (She never did run for Congress.)
Why did you decide to write a book about it?
Above all because Rosa’s odyssey to find out what happened to her oldest son, Jimmie, turned out to be such a dramatic and well documented story. And one that had never been told before. I could not have written a book without the extraordinary primary sources that revealed both the Marine Corps side of the case and Rosa’s story. The New York Times ran 57 articles and six editorials about Sutton’s death and the larger implications of it. So I realized that in the decade before World War I, this unusual story was about way more than one mother’s crusade to find out the truth about why her son died.
We were living in Washington, D.C. when my research started about 25 years ago. In addition to the vast newspaper coverage of the case, the most important original documents were in our National Archives. The staff there was terrific and I got to know the members of the Marine Corps who were involved in the brawl that took Jimmie Sutton’s life through their extensive personnel files. The turning point came when we discovered the transcript of the unparalleled naval investigation that riveted the nation during the sweltering Annapolis summer of 1909. It was over 1500 pages long. (The two volumes had been misfiled in the Archives, so historians had not written about it before.)
Who was Rosa Sutton and why was she so preoccupied with saving her son's soul?
Rosa was the daughter of pioneers who came from Ohio on the Oregon Trail to what was then the frontier town of Vancouver, Washington, in about 1850. As the seventh of 12 children, she learned how to stick up for herself as a young girl. Her father, Joseph Brant, died when she was 12; Rosa and her siblings were educated by the Sisters of Charity of Providence. From these nuns she learned that nothing is more important for a Catholic than the salvation of your immortal soul.
When the book opens, Rosa is a conservative, patriotic mother of five living in Portland, Oregon, with her very patient husband, railroad executive, James Sutton. Her contemporaries characterized her as funny, irreverent, stubborn, impetuous and anxious as well as savvy and smart.
Tragedy struck in October 1907 when the family learned that 2nd Lieutenant James N. Sutton Jr. had died on the grounds of the Naval Academy. The Navy’s quick suicide verdict was unacceptable. The Catholic Church considered suicide an immortal sin that would keep “Jimmie” from being reunited with his loved ones in the afterlife. Plus, he could’ve been condemned to the eternal punishments of hell. Rosa wanted her son to be buried in a state of grace with the church and not be in an unforgiven state. (These days the church has a more compassionate view of suicide.) The more she and her attorneys learned, the more it became clear that the hasty suicide verdict was likely not to be true.
Another important motivating force throughout Rose’s journey, of course, is the fact that she was convinced Jimmie’s ghost had visited her more than once and proclaimed his innocence.
What makes her story a timeless one?
Losing a child is the worst motherhood moment possible. The impact of such a tragedy leads to sorrow that never ends. And throughout history, perhaps especially for military families, this devastating experience is made much worse if the family doesn’t know what really happened. To a certain extent, at least to Americans at the turn of the 20th century, Rosa Sutton represented every mother who lost a child in a mysterious way and was determined to learn the truth.
Three mothers who lost their Army sons in Iraq and Afghanistan in 2004 helped me understand Rosa’s journey in a visceral way. These women had to fight to find out the truth and, like Rosa, they were aided by the press or the media available at the time. Rosa only had print journalists to help her out, but Peggy Buryj, Karen Meredith, and Mary Tillman have been able to use broadcast journalists, too, and our more sophisticated media ecosystem to finally learn the facts about what happened to Army Pfc. Jesse Buryj, Lieutenant Kenneth Ballard, and Cpl. Pat Tillman. These mothers’ journeys, discussed in the Prologue and Epilogue of the 2026 book, had many parallels to Rosa’s journey. As mothers they all felt that their lost sons were by their sides while they fought for justice and accountability. And they have kept up the memory of their sons for over two decades.
A Soul on Trial is also timeless because it is about speaking truth to power and the rights we have been given in the United States by our First Amendment. America’s press corps plays a critical role in allowing Rosa to find justice and her own form of redemption. Her sense of her own agency, before women had the right to vote, comes from our Constitution.
How did you choose the images on the front cover of the book and why add a tiny white dove?
A Soul on Trial is a true story that unfolds on more than one level. An image of a building at the United States Naval Academy, Mahan Hall, dominates the cover. This imposing Beaux Arts Academic Building, constructed in 1907, represents the power of the United States Navy. It’s a monumental structure, highly symmetrical in its design, suggesting strength, order and discipline; the façade includes nautical motifs and the building is anchored by a lofty central clock tower. Time is of the essence in the military. And this is the building where the sensational “trial” took place in 1909 that is the centerpiece of the book.
After we had the initial concept for the cover, it seemed something needed to represent the more ethereal and spiritual side of the story. But why the dove? I have always loved doves and find the sound of doves comforting. Both the Old and New Testaments make frequent references to doves as symbolic representations of the Holy Spirit. Christianity still accepts the white dove as a metaphor for the Holy Spirit, a sign of purity and new beginnings. In early Christian catacomb paintings, a dove signified the departed soul that had found its way to God. So the dove could suggest Jimmie Sutton’s soul on the way to Heaven. For his grieving mother, the fate of this soul was undecided for almost two years while millions of American citizens, as well as newspaper reporters, military officials, congressmen, and attorneys tried to learn the elusive truth about the early morning fight on October 13, 1907, that left Second Lt. Sutton dead.
Then there are the more otherworldly, inexplicable experiences Rosa had. She was not a spiritualist; she never consulted a medium. Any attempt to communicate with the dead was strictly forbidden by her church. So when she and several witnesses attested to the fact that the ghost of her son appeared to her more than once to tell her what really happened on the night he died, much of America was both puzzled and intrigued.
What kind of mystery is your book?
A Soul on Trial is a narrative non-fiction historical mystery that, many say, reads like fiction. But because it’s not fiction, it’s a bit more complex than some mysteries. Based on years of research, the book follows multiple threads that puzzled contemporaries who wanted to find out what really happened to a young Marine Corps lieutenant. And who wanted to support his mother’s right to know. It’s a unique true crime story made all the more puzzling by the fact that the officer’s grieving mother was convinced she had several encounters with the spirit of her dead son who told her what really happened.
Was Lieutenant Sutton murdered? Did his mother really see his ghost? These two questions preoccupied Americans from all walks of life between 1907 and 1910. When there was no radio or television, and certainly no Internet. It’s intriguing to imagine how this story might play today and what Rosa might have to say on Instagram or other forms of social media.
No comments:
Post a Comment